Most chamber boards are made up of smart, accomplished people who care deeply about the community.
That’s not the problem.
The problem is that smart, accomplished people don’t automatically operate as a team.
A board becomes a force when trust replaces politeness, when alignment replaces assumption, and when members stop performing based on what they think is expected (in their own minds) and start owning outcomes together. That kind of cohesion doesn’t come from agendas alone. It comes from shared experiences that shift how people see each other.
That’s where unexpected activities earn their keep. You have to go beyond ice breakers into something that helps cement the bonds between them, forming a cohesive group and not a dog and pony show.
Design for Disruption, not Comfort
Many boards fall into comfortable patterns quickly. Same seats every meeting. Same voices first. Same alliances and support. Over time, those patterns harden into cliques (yes, just like middle school). Not intentionally necessarily, but predictably.
The reason cliques are a problem is that they quietly (or sometimes not so quietly) shape power dynamics. They influence whose ideas get traction and whose stay unspoken. Newer board members can feel like guests and may feel like their voices aren’t heard when they don’t support the thoughts of the clique. Longtime members can feel like gatekeepers without meaning to.
The solution isn’t calling it out. It’s designing around it.
Intentional disruption breaks autopilot. When people are mixed on purpose, they listen more carefully. They explain instead of assuming. They build relationships across tenure, industry, and personality.
A simple rule goes a long way: no one sits with the same person twice.
Now layer in activities that make that mixing matter.
The “Business Origin Story” Exchange
Pair board members from different industries and tenure levels. Give each person five minutes to answer one question: What problem did you originally set out to solve when you started your business or career?
The listener’s job isn’t to respond or relate it back to themselves. It’s to introduce their partner to the full board afterward using that story.
This does two things. It builds empathy fast, and it trains board members to advocate for one another. That advocacy carries into meetings when ideas are on the table. It also can build a shared vision even between professionals in vastly different areas. “Oh, you wanted to overcome that problem? So did I.”
The Silent Strategy Build
Break the board into small, mixed groups. Give them a chamber challenge to solve, but with one rule: the first ten minutes are silent. Everyone writes ideas on sticky notes or cards. Only after ideas are visible does discussion begin.
This levels the playing field instantly. If your board meetings are plagued by the same several loud voices and others looking like they want to contribute only to “forget” what they were saying or say “it’s already been said” when you know they just don’t feel comfortable voicing it, this silent brainstorming can make a difference.
Dominant voices pause. Thoughtful processors contribute early. Quieter members are heard without interruption. The group often realizes how much insight was sitting in the room all along.
Role Reversal Roundtables
Assign each board member a role they don’t normally occupy. A small business owner argues from the city’s perspective. A public-sector leader takes on the lens of a startup founder. A longtime board member speaks as if they’re brand new.
The goal of this exercise is perspective. It softens entrenched positions and builds respect for the complexity of decisions the chamber navigates. It also exposes assumptions that may be limiting progress.
The Rotating Ally Challenge
At the start of a meeting, assign each board member a temporary ally. Their job for the duration of the meeting is to ensure their ally’s ideas are acknowledged and clarified if needed. Allies rotate each meeting.
This breaks up familiar alliances and encourages active listening. It also creates a culture where board members look out for one another’s contributions, not just their own priorities.
The Values-In-Action Walk
Instead of discussing values abstractly, take the board on a short walk or site visit in the community. Ask each person to point out one example of the chamber’s values in action and one gap they see.
Movement changes energy. Shared observation creates shared language. The conversation becomes grounded in real-world impact instead of theory.
End with mixed small groups discussing what the chamber could do next to close one gap they noticed.
These activities aren’t about fun for fun’s sake. They’re about rewiring how the board operates. They dissolve cliques without drama, flatten hierarchy without disrespect, and they turn individuals into collaborators.
You’re not trying to build a group of best friends here. That’s not what a cohesive board is. A cohesive board means everyone feels connected enough to disagree productively, advocate for one another, and move in the same direction once a decision is made.
When you design experiences that create connection, clarity, and mutual respect, the board starts functioning like a leadership body. And that’s when you can start feeling the momentum.
And that is when board members get more engaged and contributing at a higher level.
Share this post with your chamber colleagues, board, and members
Schedule a free 30 minute call with Frank
Take Advantage of Our Chamber Industry Services
Join with 12,000+ Chamber Pros in the Chamber Pros Community Facebook Group (For FREE)
Training and Resources for Chamber of Commerce Professionals
Done 4 You Social Media Content for Your Chamber Of Commerce
Board Retreats, Strategic Plans, Board Training, Consulting, and More...
Meet Our Authors
Hi, I'm Frank Kenny
Founder of the Chamber Pros Community
Hi, I'm Norma Davey
Founder of the Co-Chamber Pros Community
Most Recent Posts
Subscribe to the Chamber Pros Community eNewsletter.
Discover chamber tips, strategies, and best practices...
We value your privacy and will never sell your info