9 Ways To Win Members Over png

From the cost of eggs to fast food, everyone is talking about rising costs. As a chamber pro, you’re likely hearing a lot of businesses say there’s simply no money in the budget for membership. But what they’re really saying is—we don’t know the value of chamber membership. After all, would a business tell the power company there’s no money in the budget for electricity? Of course not. They know they need electricity to perform their job and literally keep the lights on.

When the economy tightens and businesses start cutting costs, chamber memberships can land on the chopping block if the business doesn’t understand the value of membership. But the reality is—that’s exactly when they need you the most.

The challenge isn’t just about selling a membership; it’s about showing undeniable value in a climate where every dollar counts.

9 Ways to Win Members Over

If your chamber is feeling the economic pressure, here are real-world strategies you can use to not only retain current members but also bring in new ones—even when everyone claims they “don’t have the budget right now.”


1. Stop Selling Membership. Start Solving Problems.

Don’t lead with benefits. Lead with pain points. Businesses right now are worried about sales, employee retention, AI disruption, foot traffic, tariffs, and surviving next quarter. Your pitch should start with, “What are you struggling with right now?” and then show exactly how your chamber helps solve that problem.

Try This: Create a "Top 5 Problems We Help Solve" sheet to hand out at networking events or send in follow-up emails.


2. Offer a Payment Plan (and Talk About It!)

A $400 annual membership might feel like a lot, but $33/month? That’s less than a cell phone bill and barely more than Netflix. Break down your dues into manageable monthly payments—and don’t wait for them to ask. Promote it upfront.

Bonus Tip: If your system doesn’t automate this yet, just offer to invoice manually. The convenience is worth the work. Just make sure your monthly option is credit card or ACH payment only that you will run on an arranged upon day each month. You don’t want to spend half the month chasing money.


3. Build “Micro-Wins” Into Membership

Micro is the word of the day with businesses and for good reason, it feels manageable and tangible. “Micro” anything denotes small-scale shifts in behavior, mindset, or tech that signal bigger changes ahead, and they’re super useful for sparking content, guiding innovation, or refreshing your messaging.

Plus, business owners love quick wins. Instead of promoting vague benefits like “advocacy” or “networking,” show immediate value and get on board with the micro trend.

Example:

  • Join now and get a free video interview featured on our Instagram and newsletter.
  • New members get a free business spotlight in our local newspaper insert
  • We’ll announce your membership to 6,000 local contacts and tag your business

Make it hard to say no.


4. Create a “Return on Investment” Calculator

A visual ROI calculator or checklist helps potential members see what they’re getting. Even if it’s rough, frame it like:

Benefit                                                              Value 

Featured in Member Directory          $150 

Ribbon Cutting / PR Support               $200

Monthly Networking Events               $300 

Advocacy on Local Issues                       Priceless 

Social Media Welcome Post                 $100 

Newsletter Spotlights (6x/year)        $600 


Total Estimated Value:                            $1,350+


Now compare that to a $400 membership.

Show. Don’t just tell.


5. Use Scarcity the Right Way

Create urgency by offering limited-time perks or member-only events that are too good to miss.

“Join by [date] and get exclusive access to our VIP business bootcamp.”

“New members this quarter get free promo at our signature event.”

But don’t leave existing members out either. Offer them a bonus for renewing early. Don’t be like the cable or cellphone companies that reward new and forget loyalty.


6. Incentivize Members to Sell for You

Turn your biggest fans into your sales team. Not only will that help alleviate the work you/your team have to do, but word-of-mouth marketing is much more effective coming from members than someone on the chamber payroll.

Offer referral bonuses like:

  • 1 free month of membership (or free event ticket) for every referral
  • Entry into a “Win Your Membership Free” drawing
  • Shoutouts or business features for top referrers

And more importantly—ask for their assistance. Most people are willing to help but won’t think about it on their own. Ask them which businesses in their network could benefit from chamber membership.


7. Build a “First-Year Experience” Funnel

Once they join, your work isn’t done. The real sales strategy? Retention, of course. Design a 12-month onboarding experience that includes:

  • A new member checklist
  • Intro email series highlighting one benefit each week
  • Quarterly check-in calls
  • Invitations to exclusive “new member only” events, intros, etc.

When someone makes the decision to join, they’re in the honeymoon period. It doesn’t take a lot to continue to make them happy. You’re starting off on a positive note. But you want to build on that positivity to the point that they end up saying, “I should’ve joined earlier!”


8. Partner with Local Banks, Realtors, or Vendors

Some organizations want to give back to the local economy and be seen by new members such as banks, real estate agents, and other vendors. A great way to do this is by allowing them to sponsor a small business’s first-year membership or the onboarding program extras. You’ll support new members AND create champions in the community.


9. Rebrand Membership as Growth Support

Membership can feel like an outdated word in some industries and member organizations are struggling. Plus, it doesn’t convey value. “I’m a member but what do I get?” Replace the word “membership” with language that resonates now such as:

- Business Boost Program

- Local Growth Collective

- Small Business Accelerator


The idea of membership is alive and strong just look at Costco or physicians offering a concierge patient membership service. Sometimes, it’s not what you’re selling—it’s how you position it. The term membership may not be enough for everything your chamber offers.

In lean times, your chamber shouldn’t shrink—it should step up. Businesses are looking for lifelines, not luxuries. If they tell you they can’t afford membership, help them see the value behind this business investment. Make your chamber the tool they can’t live without.

Sell support, community, and momentum—not just access to a newsletter or event calendar.

CUSTOM JAVASCRIPT / HTML
CUSTOM JAVASCRIPT / HTML
Social Share Buttons

Share this post with your chamber colleagues, board, and members

Schedule a free 30 minute call with Frank

CUSTOM JAVASCRIPT / HTML

Take Advantage of Our Chamber Industry Services

Join with 12,000+ Chamber Pros in the Chamber Pros Community Facebook Group (For FREE)

Training and Resources for Chamber of Commerce Professionals

Done 4 You Social Media Content for Your Chamber Of Commerce

Board Retreats, Strategic Plans, Board Training, Consulting, and More...

Meet Our Authors

Christina Metcalf jpg

Writer for the Chamber Pros Community

Frank-head-shot-2-small jpg

Hi, I'm Frank Kenny

Founder of the Chamber Pros Community

Z6UCUCaQ_400x400 jpeg

Hi, I'm Norma Davey

Founder of the Co-Chamber Pros Community

Most Recent Posts

CUSTOM JAVASCRIPT / HTML

Subscribe to the Chamber Pros Community eNewsletter.

CPC-WEB LOGO png

Discover chamber tips, strategies, and best practices...

We value your privacy and will never sell your info

Legal Agreements, Privacy Policy, Terms and Conditions 
Copyright 2023 Chamber Pros Community and Frank J. Kenny, LLC